SDFL Rules Favor Remote Attendance

Next month, new mediation rules take effect in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida. After hearing from the bar on format and giving the public an opportunity to comment, the federal court decided in favor of remote attendance. Unless the court orders otherwise, under Local Rule 16.2, Court Annexed Mediation, the parties shall decide whether their mediation conference will be conducted in person or by video-conference and, if the parties cannot agree, the mediation conference shall be held by video-conference. Additionally, unless excused in writing by the court, all parties and required claims professionals (e.g., insurance adjusters) must participate in the mediation conference with full authority to negotiate a settlement which includes connecting and participating by video and audio. Lately, we've seen some parties appear with black screens, muted on Zoom. This change seems to attempt to address that trend and level the playing field, alleviating the need for mediators to compromise their neutrality in acting as policemen for the process. See more here for rules that take effect December 1, 2022-- https://www.flsd.uscourts.gov/sites/flsd/files/adminorders/2022-88.pdf

Sanctions for Shaq Skipping and Skyping into Mediation

In a Florida federal case, lawyers were sanctioned for advising their client, former NBA All-Star Shaquille O’Neal, that he didn’t need to personally attend court-ordered mediation. United States District Judge James Cohn of the Southern District of Florida ordered lawyers to pay $13,000 to cover mediation costs for a plaintiff who sued Shaq for allegedly ridiculing his appearance. Plaintiff has a rare genetic disorder that causes tooth loss and facial deformities and has since started an anti-bullying campaign on Facebook that attracted 20,000 members. Shaq posted a photo of himself on Instagram and Twitter stating "smile people" and imitating plaintiff's facial expressions. The lawsuit alleges defamation and invasion of privacy, though Shaq maintains there was no right to privacy because the photos were already on Instagram. He also said his conduct wasn’t so outrageous or extreme as to establish liability. Shaq reportedly attended via Skype and sent a representative to participate on his behalf, due to a television appearance conflict on the day of the mediation. The mediation order stated pursuant to Local Rule 16.2.E, the appearance of counsel and each party or a representative of each party with full authority to enter into a full and complete compromise and settlement is mandatory. The local rule says all parties shall be physically present at the mediation conference “unless excused in writing by the presiding judge.” Counsel argued unsuccessfully that the magistrate judge’s mediation order superseded the local rule, but local rule requires a federal district judge, not a magistrate judge, to excuse a party’s attendance in writing. See stories here-- http://bit.ly/1oLnNos and http://bit.ly/1oLnNos and local rule for court annexed mediation in the Southern District of Florida here-- http://1.usa.gov/1SYVSxx