Orlando Mediator Lawrence Kolin explores current issues in Alternative Dispute Resolution, including mediation and arbitration of complex cases by neutrals resulting in settlement of state and federal litigation and appeals. This blog covers a wide variety of topics-- local, national, and international-- and includes the latest on technology and Online Dispute Resolution affecting sophisticated lawyers and parties to lawsuits.
Showing posts with label enforcing arbitration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label enforcing arbitration. Show all posts
Thursday, May 25, 2023
My Pillow CEO Faces Confirmation of Award
MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell offered to pay $5 million to anyone who could debunk his evidence of interference in the 2020 presidential election. A vocal supporter of the former President, Lindell believed that the 2020 election was stolen, and that he had the evidence to prove it. There was a catch, however, as Lindell required that any such claims be submitted to an arbitrator, and the terms were written quite narrowly–but perhaps not narrowly enough. A computer forensics expert who had apparently voted for Trump twice, took Lindell up on his challenge. He analyzed the supposed evidence and demonstrated there was nothing of any sort of election interference. Lindell's terms required that he show the data had nothing to do with the 2020 presidential election. When Lindell refused to pay, the matter went to arbitration. There, despite Lindell having written the terms to make recovery difficult, the arbitrators sided with the forensic expert, Robert Zeidman, who has now filed in federal court. According to Case Western Reserve University School of Law Professor Jonathan Adler, Lindell may not have learned much about election administration through these travails, but it appears he is about to learn something about the enforceability of arbitration awards. Reportedly, Lindell is also facing multiple defamation suits from Dominion Voting Systems and former Dominion executives, and has been hit with legal sanctions for frivolous legal claims. See more here-- https://tinyurl.com/s4vr4rd2
Sunday, January 14, 2018
SCOTUS Denies Cert on 5th DCA Ruling Against Arb
The U.S. Supreme Court declined last week to review an appellate ruling by Florida's Fifth District Court of Appeal (5th DCA) that found a patient arbitration agreement unenforceable because it ran afoul of state law, despite the health care provider’s warnings that the ruling could render other health care arbitration agreements here unenforceable. The U.S. Supreme Court refused to grant Kindred Hospital East LLC's certiorari petition, just the latest in a series of long-running battles over the enforceability of health care arbitration agreements. Kindred asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review the state appeals court’s refusal to force the arbitration of medical malpractice claims, saying the decision violates the Federal Arbitration Act. The fundamental dispute lies between state courts and the high court over the scope of the Federal Arbitration Act, as both sides in the dispute argue in their briefs. Kindred asserted if the ruling below was permitted to stand, every contractual agreement to arbitrate healthcare disputes in Florida would be unenforceable. The underlying Plaintiff had sued Kindred and several doctors for medical malpractice in state court after she suffered unspecified injuries during a 2012 stay at an Ocala hospital, a move Kindred argued was prohibited by an arbitration agreement signed by both parties. Florida's 5th DCA sided with the Plaintiff in the summer of 2016 and overturned a trial court’s ruling that compelled the parties to go to arbitration, per the terms of the contract. The appeals court found that the arbitration agreement was invalid because it selectively incorporated provisions from Florida’s own Medical Malpractice Act (MMA) that were favorable to Kindred and left out provisions favorable to patients. Specifically, public policy prohibits the enforcement of an arbitration provision that incorporates some, but not all, of the MMA's arbitration provisions. See more here-- http://bit.ly/2mw6Nmf and http://bit.ly/2EG8ipq and http://bit.ly/2FDvSoj
Wednesday, January 4, 2017
Nursing Home Arbitration Ban Postponed
Last fall, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), an agency under Health and Human Services (HHS), essentially barred any nursing home or assisted living facility that receives federal funding from requiring that its residents resolve any disputes in arbitration, instead of in court. It was the most significant overhaul of the agency’s rules governing federal funding of long-term care facilities in decades. The nursing home industry maintains arbitration offers a less costly alternative to court. Allowing more lawsuits, the industry says, could drive up costs and force some homes to close. This was the case in the early 2000s, when many excess verdicts were recorded in Florida, forcing players out of the state or out of business altogether. Lawyers who work with the elderly say that people are being admitted to nursing homes at one of the most stressful moments of their lives. When CMS essentially barred any requiring residents to resolve any disputes in arbitration, federal courts were quick to issue injunctions in industry suits. Now CMS has issued a memo that it will not attempt to enforce the ban until the injunction is lifted. With the impending Trump Administration, it seems possible that the new CMS rule will die altogether. Congressional Republicans have vowed to roll back many regulations approved in the final months of the Obama Administration, such as this one. I do a fair amount of long-term care arbitrations, usually serving as the chair of a panel. These are difficult cases and are sometimes better suited to be resolved in private before knowledgeable and fair neutrals, rather than presented to juries. Arbitration of health care cases can be streamlined for counsel, saving the parties costs and often providing a quicker result than the courts. See more here-- http://bit.ly/2ibNZ8G and http://bit.ly/2j5R8XK
Monday, April 4, 2016
Arbitration to the Main Stage
In an action by several exotic dancers and entertainers against the operators of Rachel’s Adult Entertainment and Steakhouse in West Palm Beach, a federal judge granted a the strip club’s motion to compel arbitration in a Fair Labor Standards Act (FSLA), finding the entertainers' objections to agreements they signed unpersuasive or incorrect. Plaintiffs sought unpaid wages, claiming they were misclassified as independent contractors and that defendants failed to pay them a proper minimum wage and overtime as workers. Enforcement of the arbitration clause had been objected to because it was asserted all pages were not provided to dancers when they signed the agreements, which they claimed was under duress. Others argued they did not understand the arbitration clause due to language barriers. However, testimony given at an evidentiary hearing was deemed not fully credible by U.S. District Judge Robin Rosenberg. The club provided evidence that the documents were prepared by a third party who routinely stapled the pages together before delivering them. “The court can discern no credible basis for defendants or agents of defendants to choose to extract signature pages for certain dancers, and not others,” Judge Rosenberg wrote. “Thus, the court concludes that plaintiffs must rise or fall together. Either defendants systematically engaged in a pattern of practice of removing signature pages at the time of execution or defendants did not.” She also found the dancers’ claim of duress was without merit because the defendants provided evidence that no one was penalized for asking for more time to read the documents. “Florida law also places a strong duty on signatories to read the contents of the contract before signing,” wrote the court. Apparently, language barrier claims were exaggerated and mostly raised by a claimant who provided substantial testimony in English. The judge further stated that FLSA claims are routinely arbitrated, that the plaintiffs’ counsel had recently moved for arbitration on FLSA claims in an analogous case, that the arbitrator has the authority to sever portions of the agreement that are invalid or unenforceable, and that the Eleventh Circuit has held that when an arbitration agreement invokes the rules of the American Arbitration Association (AAA), as this one does, then it is clear the arbitrator is expected to determine if the agreement is valid. See more on story here-- bit.ly/1TvUgLm and case-- Monteverde et al. v. West Palm Beach Food and Beverage LLC, case number 9:15-cv-81203, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida
Wednesday, September 16, 2015
EEOC Seeks Carve-outs in Employment Arbitration Clauses
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) processed nearly ninety thousand charges last year. Reportedly, the EEOC will not hesitate to take action against employers that prevent employees from filing EEOC claims, which includes mandatory arbitration agreements. Such agreements should contain a carve-outs that expressly allow employees to file EEOC charges, as one franchisee of major restaurant chains in Florida recently learned. The company had a mandatory arbitration provision with no exception for the filing of administrative charges by employees with the EEOC. The EEOC sued, alleging such agreements constitute a pattern and practice of resistance to rights secured by Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. Thus far, a federal court ruled that the EEOC was authorized to file suit against employers in the absence of an underlying charge of discrimination. The court also ruled that the EEOC had standing to sue, itself, even if not a party to the arbitration agreement in question. In what was perhaps a subsequent remedial measure, the company already amended its agreements. Interestingly, the EEOC is on record in strong support of voluntary alternative dispute resolution programs that resolve employment discrimination disputes in a fair and credible manner, and are entered into after a dispute has arisen. It has even recognized that while even the best arbitral systems do not afford the benefits of the judicial system, well-designed ADR programs, including binding arbitration, can offer in particular cases other valuable benefits to civil rights claimants, such as relative savings in
time and expense. However, it seems depriving employees of their right to file EEOC administrative charges will not be tolerated by the current EEOC, even if the employees will ultimately have to arbitrate their claims rather than litigate them in court. See more here--http://onforb.es/1KRSqS9 and http://www.eeoc.gov/policy/docs/mandarb.html
Tuesday, September 1, 2015
UNCITRAL & International Settlements
The United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) was established by United Nations General Assembly Resolution 2205 in 1966 to promote the progressive harmonization and unification of international trade law. Lack of framework for the enforcement of settlement agreements is why international parties are often reluctant to resort to mediation, notwithstanding its effectiveness as a method of ADR. In order to promote mediation and solidify the enforceability of settlement agreements, efforts by UNCITRAL are underway to find a solution. Last summer, during a session of UNCITRAL that took place in New York, a proposal to undertake work on the preparation of a convention on the enforceability of international commercial settlement agreements reached through mediation/conciliation was put forward to UNCITRAL by the United States. Accordingly, Working Group II (WGII)-- one of six working groups established by UNCITRAL, specifically relating to arbitration and conciliation-- was assigned to perform the substantive preparatory work. This group was requested to consider the proposal and report back to UNCITRAL on the feasibility and possible form of work in that area. During a recent session of UNCITRAL that took place in Vienna, WGII reported to UNCITRAL a summary of its findings, its concerns and recommendations. UNCITRAL approved giving WGII a mandate to work on the topic of enforcement of settlement agreements resulting from international commercial conciliation. Reportedly, the mandate given by UNCITRAL to the WGII is broad enough to include different possible forms of work, namely: (i) a guidance text, (ii) a model legislative provisions, and perhaps most significantly, (iii) a convention. It will be interesting to see what develops as a result of this important work. See more here-- http://bit.ly/1Xbd9no and http://www.uncitral.org/uncitral/en/commission/working_groups/2Arbitration.html
Friday, May 8, 2015
Armstrong Seeks To Vacate Arbitration Award
When cyclist Lance Armstrong finally confessed doping to Oprah Winfrey in 2013, the Dallas sports insurance company that paid him millions of dollars in victory bonuses sued for fraud, asking for its money back. After SCA accused Armstrong and filed suit which was sent to arbitration, Armstrong unsuccessfully tried for an appeal with the Texas Supreme Court to have the case blocked. The dispute with Armstrong actually began over a decade ago, after the former U.S. Postal Service team member won the 2004 Tour de France, the sixth of his seven consecutive victories. Following doping allegations, that case went to arbitration in 2005. SCA Promotions paid Armstrong $7.5 million in 2006. Evidence from that arbitration was used later against him, including testimony from a former teammate and his wife, who said they heard Armstrong admit to using performance-enhancing drugs back in 1996. Armstrong was banned for life by the United States Anti-Doping Agency and stripped of his Tour titles in August 2012. Last February, SCA won a $10 million ruling against him after this case went back to the same arbitration panel that handled the 2005 dispute. The panel said Armstrong used perjury and other wrongful conduct to secure millions of dollars of benefits from SCA. One of the three neutral panelists dissented, noting that the parties entered into a final and binding settlement agreement the last time around. The dissenter apparently believes the majority's sanction is an unwarranted, unlawful reversal of a prior settlement agreement already made and effectuated. Armstrong's attorneys reportedly say the arbitration panel exceeded its authority with its recent ruling. According to news reports, Armstrong's attorneys claim the panel's issuance of sanctions violates well-established Texas public policy favoring settlements and arbitrations for efficient and final resolution of disputes. Court documents show Armstrong and Tailwind Sports, which owned the U.S. Postal Service team for which Armstrong raced, are seeking to vacate the award, insisting it “effectively eviscerated a fully negotiated and binding settlement agreement” reached between Armstrong and SCA Promotions in 2006. The arbitrators have said, “Perjury must never be profitable.” SCA Promotions is now asking a Texas state judge to confirm the arbitration award against Armstrong. It wants the court to enter a $10 million judgment against Armstrong and the former team owner so it may proceed to collect payment. Armstrong’s lawyers maintain the dispute settled voluntarily and finally years earlier. Interestingly, Armstrong previously offered to pay SCA despite the absence of any legal basis for the sanction, and SCA refused to accept. Armstrong is also facing a $100 million fraud lawsuit from the federal government. See full stories here-- http://bit.ly/1F4qXrH and http://usat.ly/1Kqgxm2 and link to motion to vacate pleading here-- https://www.scribd.com/doc/264558280/Lance-Armstrong-Does-Not-Want-to-Pay-SCA-10-Million
Friday, May 1, 2015
Arbitration Fairness Act of 2015
There is a new bill in Congress to amend Title 9 of the United States Code with respect to arbitration over which increasing debate on fairness as a pre-dispute agreement has intensified. The Arbitration Fairness Act of 2015 was introduced by Minnesota Senator Al Franken and Georgia Representative Hank Johnson to eliminate mandatory arbitration clauses in employment, consumer, civil rights and antitrust cases. Companies provide almost all consumer financial products and services under written contracts with such clauses. Arbitration agreements in those contracts often require that parties resolve any subsequent disputes through privately-appointed arbitrators, rather than through the court system. The use of arbitration clauses has increased with recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions supporting corporate enforcement efforts of those agreements. A Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) report found that 75% of consumers surveyed did not know if they were subject to an arbitration clause in their credit card contract. Among consumers whose contract included an arbitration clause, fewer than ten percent recognized that they could not sue their credit card issuer in court. It is claimed so-called "forced arbitration" does not provide important procedural guarantees of fairness and due process that are the hallmarks of courts of law. According to Senator Franken’s office, the Arbitration Fairness Act would restore the intent of the original Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) passed by Congress in 1925. When the FAA was passed, it was intended to target commercial arbitration agreements between two companies of generally comparable bargaining power. Over the years, court decisions broadened the reach of the law to include consumer and employment disputes. Under the newly introduced Arbitration Fairness Act of 2015, agreements to arbitration of employment, consumer, civil rights and antitrust disputes could only be made after the dispute has arisen. The Act does not prohibit companies and consumers from going to arbitration to settle a dispute once the dispute has actually taken place. The Act reportedly seeks to ensure transparency in civil litigation by protecting the integrity of Civil Rights Act, the Equal Pay Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, among others. The Act would continue to allow pre-dispute mandatory arbitration to continue in business-to-business agreements, and does not apply to collective bargaining agreements. The National Consumer Law Center and the National Association of Consumer Advocates support the new measure. Both proponents and critics of the new act take hard-line stances on the perceived ills or benefits of arbitration, rather than trying to address some criticisms while preserving its benefits. Under the Bill, the applicability of an agreement to arbitrate and the validity and enforceability of an agreement is to be determined by a court, rather than an arbitrator, irrespective of whether the party resisting arbitration challenges the arbitration agreement specifically or in conjunction with other terms of the contract containing such agreement. See proposed legislation here-- http://1.usa.gov/1GC7gEr and CFPB report to Congress here-- http://1.usa.gov/1EPG8nT
Tuesday, February 25, 2014
No Waiver of Judicial Review of Fee Arbitration
In a recent decision out of the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, a panel ruled that parties cannot contractually eliminate judicial review of arbitral awards under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA). The underlying dispute concerned attorneys' fees in connection with the settlement of a class action lawsuit. Counsel could not agree on how to divide the legal fees and submitted the dispute to arbitration. Following the issuance of an award that allocated the fees among them, the lawyer that received the most money petitioned a federal district court to confirm the award under the FAA. An attorney who received the second highest amount moved to vacate the award. After the district court granted the petition to confirm and denied the motion to vacate, the decision was appealed. The appellee argued that the appellate court lacked jurisdiction due to an arbitration clause that provided made it both binding and non-appealable. The Ninth Circuit rejected that argument and held that federal court review of arbitration cannot be waived or eliminated by contract. The court found the arbitration language was ambiguous, as it could be understood to preclude review of the merits or interpreted to divest courts of any right to review awards. The court noted that permitting parties to opt out of judicial review of arbitral awards under the FAA would frustrate a minimum level of due process for parties ensured by Congress. See article here- http://bit.ly/Mrw3pv and decision here-- http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2013/12/17/11-17718.pdf
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
